Japanese title: Kikan Part 2
translation: Redux Part 2
Spanish title: Reducción II
translation: Reduction II
US Airdate: November 9, 1997
writer: Chris Carter
director: Kim Manners
STARRING:
David Duchovny as Special Agent Fox Mulder
Gillian Anderson as Special Agent Dana Scully
Mitch Pileggi as Assistant Director Skinner
Guest Cast:
William B. Davis as Cigarette Smoking Man
Ken Camroux as Senior Agent
Charles Cioffi as Blevins
Brent Sheppard as Doctor
Bruce Harwood as Byers
Dean Haglund as Langly
Tom Briadwood as Frohike
Don S. Williams as The First Elder
Sheila Larken as Mrs. Scully
Pat Skipper as Bill Scully
Robert Wright as Dr. Zuckerman
John Finn as Kritschgau
Megan Leitch as Samantha Mulder
Arnie Walters as Father McCue
With Scully lingering near death and the future of the Xfiles in
danger, the Cigarette Smoking Man comes forward with a surprising offer to save Scully's
life - and more -in the series' 100th episode.
"Where do I begin
To tell the story of how great a love can be
The sweet love story that is older than the sea
The simple truth about the love she brings to me
Where do I start?"
lyrics ripped off from "(Where Do I Begin) Love Story"
the theme from the movie "Love Story"
special thanks to Wayne Garvin and his fab Lyrics Library
<http://www.kw.igs.net/~wgarvin/lyrics.html>
Don't even bother sending me nasty mail and telling me these two
don't love each other, did you see this ep?! Okay, I'll agree, not physical, sexual love,
but darn it, Mulder loves this woman, and I shall not be swayed!
Where *do* I begin? If I had a rating system, this one would be a 10
out of 10, it had drama, comedy, tension, intrigue and a whole lotta heart. Some answers,
more questions, and a reminder of why Gillian Anderson is still the best actress on TV and
Sheila Larken needs more airtime. Over the course of an hour, my heart was in my throat,
beating like a rabbit and glowing like a hot coal. Mulder's sister returns, but is she
real? Cancer Man is killed, or is he? Scully is cured, but for how long? Blevins is
murdered, but what about his killer? For the answers to these and other questions, stay
tuned for tonight's episode of .... As The X Turns ...
Plotline
Our story opens at Trinity Hospital in Washington, D.C., 5:13AM, as
Mulder walks briskly into the building. He attempts to ask various nurses where Scully is,
with no luck or response, until he yells "Where is she?!" and a doctor finally
comes to help him, telling him that she's in the ICU (Intensive Care Unit). As the doctor
begins to lead Mulder there, Skinner appears with some FBI henchmen, his teeth firmly
clenched as only he can. He says that Mulder's "moving pretty good for a dead
man" and that he has a lot to answer for, but Mulder could care less if the whole
world now knows he's alive, he needs to see Scully. He pushes past Skinner and the boys,
going through a door as he continues his search. Skinner soon follows, on his own.
Mulder's face drops as he comes upon Scully, unconscious and hooked up to machines,
looking pale. He asks Skinner what happened to her, why she's in the hospital, and he
answers, "She's dying." Mulder loses it, and a struggle ensues as he tries to
get to her (reminiscent of One Breath, as is the whole opening scene, interesting to note
that Scully's cancer was contracted in that ep), Skinner tells him not to do this, he
doesn't want to have to arrest him. With lingering looks at Scully, Mulder quietly leaves
the hospital room and the camera focuses on her sleeping face. Cue the music, our drama
has begun!
Mulder walks into Blevins' office, accompanied by Skinner, the
Senior Agent is already there (watch him, he's important later!). Blevins and the Senior
Agent make it clear to Mulder that they're ticked, the body in his apartment will have to
be identified and murder charges laid, they want answers and they want them now. Why did
Scully lie to them? Who's protecting whom? If Mulder doesn't start talking, he's going to
damage himself in the formal inquiry. Not saying a word, he leaves Blevins' office, and
Skinner follows him.
A heated exchange commences in the hallway after Skinner tells him
to "keep playing it the way you have been". Mulder sarcastically calls Skinner
his "buddy" and asks him where he was when he needed him, why offer advice now?
Skinner tells him he's been sitting on forensic evidence on the Dod Guy in Mulder's
apartment, the proof that he was shot point blank in the temple by a handgun, then in the
face with a shotgun. Scully will verify all this (or so he says, Mulder has no idea yet
that Scully thinks Skinner is a mole). Mulder wants to know how Skinner can help him, but
Skinner needs to know why Scully lied for him. Mulder tells him that her cancer was given
to her by a mole within the FBI, one he hasn't been able to identify yet, which is all a
bit of a shock to poor Skinner, as he now knows Scully believes it's him. Skinner tells
him not to forget who his friends are, his face showing concern about his own fate.
We see the 1st Elder (also becoming known among the online fans as
FIG, for Fat Italian Guy, and FIGBT, Fat Italian Guy with Bad Teeth, among other things;
for the sake of clarity I'm sticking with the official cast listing) watching a small TV
at the racetrack, engrossed in the Hearing On Human Cloning on WWN (the hearings are real,
the network is not), as Cancer Man arrives to confirm that Mulder is indeed alive. Cancer
Man seems pleased, reminding him that he told him not to underestimate Mulder. The Elder
blames him for letting Mulder escape, and is angry that he was able to enter the Dod
complex. Cancer Man explains that Mulder is much more valuable to them alive, and with him
in trouble now, he could use their help, in exchange for his loyalty. With a smirk, he
leaves, then the Elder says to a man standing behind him, "You can proceed now."
We now see Scully, pale and weak in her hospital bed, the TV by the
nurse's desk tuned to the cloning hearings, as Mulder enters her room. Scully is shocked
to see him, concerned that his cover will be blown, but with a smile, a clutch of her hand
and a kiss on the cheek (*sigh*),
he tells her not to worry, he's officially undead and will be
testifying before the panel to everything he knows and believes. It doesn't matter now who
the mole was, Mulder says, as he tries to keep off topic by saying "How about them
Yankees?", but Scully tells him that Skinner is "dirty" and he will use
Mulder's testimony to ruin him, she pleads with him to not testify. Mulder won't have it,
if he doesn't, they'll continue to bury The Truth, so Scully tells him to blame her, tell
them she shot Ostelhoff, "if I can save you, let me." With another beautiful
Mulder-smile, he refuses. As Mrs. Scully and Bill Jr. arrive, he kisses her hand and
leaves the room.
As he walks out, he shakes Bill Jr.'s hand, introducing himself for
the first time. Bill Jr. is not pleased, and asks that "business" be kept at bay
and that Dana be allowed to die with dignity (such a pessimist!). He goes into Scully's
room, as Mulder watches the family scene through the
window.
As we look down on "Vertigo"-style winding steps, a man
walks up the stairs and stops to open a briefcase. The man is the same one the Elder spoke
to, his briefcase contains a high-powered rifle in various pieces!
Back to the hospital, as Mulder turns a corner in the hallway,
Cancer Man appears and Mulder says "Please tell me you're here with severe chest
pain" (my favorite line in the whole hour, cracked me up!). Cancer Man tells him he's
there to congratulate him on finding the cure for Scully in the DoD complex. Mulder says
he didn't find anything of use, but Cancer Man insists he did, step outside and he'll
explain. Mulder hesitates, Cancer Man says "I'm here tonight as a friend, Agent
Mulder", looking rather friendly, I must say, and Mulder finally walks out with him.
We now see Mulder with the Lone Gunmen as they investigate the vial
again, shaking out a micro-chip that had been protected by the deionized water (what are
you guys, slipping?! It was there all along, you gits! Sheesh!). The boys are confused,
have they found a cure for cancer? No, explains Mulder, just Scully's cancer, as she only
contracted it when the micro-chip she'd had implanted at the back of her neck had been
removed. As Frohike so eloquently puts it, "Too freakin' amazing!".
Kritschgau arrives at the FBI panel room, as the questions begin
about his knowledge of the DoD Guy's murder. He admits that he was in contact with Mulder
and Scully, and when he's asked why he handed over classified information to them, he says
he has knowledge of a government conspiracy against the American people. Everyone on the
panel looks at each other, is this guy for real? The Senior Agent sidetracks that query,
and asks if Kritschgau knows who killed the Dod Guy, he answers that he doesn't. He's then
asked if his death has any connection to Mulder and Scully, to which he says, no, but he
is aware of one death in connection, his own son that died earlier that morning. No one
bothers to offer condolances, the questioning continues. Is he employed by the DoD? Yes,
technically, but he also recieves money from another source, a
congressional lobbying firm called Roush. Skinner asks him if he
knows what this Roush is, which he doesn't and Skinner writes the name down (interesting
that he didn't ask how to spell it, hmmmm?! More Roush stuff in the Notes).
Scully is holding the vial with the micro-chip, as Mulder, her
mother, brother and doctor stand around her hospital room. Bill Jr. is furious that Mulder
actually thinks this will cure his sister, it's just "science-fiction", the
doctor's never heard of it, how dare he presume to know what's good for Scully?! She
quietly states that although everyone has their heart in the right place, the final
decision is hers, and she doesn't think Bill Jr. has all the facts. Her doctor, when
Mulder asks if she'll have to stop conventional treatment, tells them that he only has
unconventional treatments to use on her cancer now, they've done everything else. Scully
wants to try the micro-chip, everyone looks at each other, concern etched in their faces.
The scene cuts to the assassin putting together his rifle (boy, how
long has he been working on that?!), and checking his watch, it's 10:30, whatever *that*
means.
Mulder is now seated outside Scully's room, as Bill Jr. walks out.
He quietly, but surely, tears a strip off Mulder, blaming him for Melissa's death and
what's happened to Dana, all because of his search for "little green aliens".
Resisting the temptation to correct him (see Squeeze), Mulder sits back and takes it as
Bill Jr. calls him a "sorry son of a bitch" and walks away. Mulder's phone
rings, it's Cancer Man checking on Scully's progress. Mulder doesn't know yet if the
micro-chip will work,
thus he still doesn't trust Cancer Man, so he has one more thing to
offer Mulder, a meeting he has arranged.
Cut to a small diner somewhere, Mulder is the only customer seated
at the counter. The waitress is laying out some condiments, she puts down a bottle and
says to him, "Tobassco, cures anything" with a knowing nod (cuff her, Mulder,
she knows something we don't!). Mulder looks at the clock which reads 9:32, getting antsy
about this "meeting". A car's headlights flood the room as it pulls up. Mulder
walks to the door, his eyes squinting at the light as it covers him (eerily similar to how
the car's passenger "left" him in the first place), and as the lights are turned
off, he sees Cancer Man in the driver's seat (figuratively and literally). The passenger
is Samantha! She gets out of the car, and through tears, tells him she didn't think she'd
ever see him again, that he had always told her something had happened to him that night.
When Mulder asks who told her that, she nods toward the car and says, "My
father". Mulder's face contorts into a look of shock and confusion.
The clock now says 10:13 and they're inside the diner, talking about
her life as she has known it. The memories of what happened when she was 8 are vague, and
she has tried to forget them, being told she was an orphan, being taken to meet Cancer Man
as her father by her foster parents. She was told that it had all been a secret, that her
mother and Cancer Man had tried to protect the family. Mulder questions why she believes
him, and she says he had been so kind to her and that he was the only one she could
remember from before it happened (odd, I thought, as Mulder has no childhood memories of
Cancer Man). He asks her what she remembers from The Night, and through tears she tells
him she remembers him, something about men, then nothing. Mulder wants to help her
remember that she was abducted, but she doesn't want to. So why come
here? he asks. Because her "father" (still gives me chills
to think about!) told her he had found Mulder, that he had been looking for her for a long
time, was it true? Mulder begins to cry and tries to explain that That Man cannot be
trusted, he has "known where I've been for a very long time". She doesn't
understand and refuses to believe him, he's been a good father to her, gave her a life and
was there for her when noone else was. Mulder says he wants to take her to see Mom.
Samantha is shocked, thinking she was dead. This is all too much for her and she wants to
go, she'd been afraid to see him, she has a life now, children of her own. Fox grasps her
hand, begging her to at least tell him how to contact her, but she says she needs time and
promises to think about it, "please ... let me go". He reluctantly releases her
hand, watching her with tears in his eyes as she gets back in the car, Cancer Man tenderly
caressing her cheek.
We see Scully being injected with flourodeoxyglucose (sp?) by her
doctor, it will show up on the PET scan and tell them right away if her cancer is
subsiding. Scully asks him if he's ever seen a miracle, and he says he has seen people
recover when they were so far gone as to be a write-off, but he doesn't dare call them
miracles.
Mulder is walking down a street, his head in the cross-hairs of the
assassin's rifle, as Cancer Man meets up with him. He apologizes to Mulder for having to
leave so quickly after the previous evening's meeting. Mulder wants to know why he has
been given pieces of what he wants and Cancer Man says he is ready to offer him The Truth
he has been desperately seeking, that Kritschgau has told him nothing but "beautiful
lies", made him think that all he's ever believed about the existence of
extraterrestrial life is untrue. Cancer Man can show him The Truth. Mulder wants to know
what it will cost him, Cancer Man tells him to quit the FBI and come work for him, all his
problems will disappear. Just when we start to think maybe Mulder will go for it, he tells
him to shove it, in so many words :-). He's given Mulder nothing, and he blames him for
Scully's cancer, Melissa's death, his own father's murder, global warming and the hole in
the ozone layer! Well, just about anyway. If Scully dies, "I will kill you! I don't
care whose father you are, I will put you down!". He walks away as Cancer Man tells
him the offer's still open if he reconsiders and we see the assassin put down his gun.
In what is, to me, the most beautiful, touching, heart-breaking
scene of this entire episode, Scully talks to her mother about her faith, holding her
cross necklace and asking "why do I wear this?". She's had the micro-chip
implanted and gone through the doctor's "crazy treatments", but feels she's
doing nothing, that she's pushed her faith away when she needs it the most. Her mother
tries to convince her that she still has her faith, and she will get better, but Dana says
her tests have, so far, shown no improvement. Her mother knows Dana is afraid, but she has
to tell someone.
Next we see the Elder watching the cloning hearings. He is shocked
(I'm guessing, the man has no emotional range) to see Skinner settle into one of the seats
and he calls someone on the phone, telling them Skinner is there collecting information
for someone. Why wasn't the FBI problem cleared up? he asks. Handle it now, and he will
fix it for good.
NOTE: This is merely my opinion of what Mulder is thinking in the
following scene.
At a loss concerning his sister's return and disappearance (again),
churning over the deal Cancer Man has offered him, Mulder goes to seek comfort with the
only person left in his life, Scully. He quietly enters her room in the night as she
sleeps. He sits next to her and lays his head beside her on the bed. He holds her hand,
using it to stifle his silent screams as he cries (killer scene, even if he does appear to
be biting her at first).
Mulder has been called to Blevins' office. They're alone, just the
two of them, which should send alarm bells ringing for Mulder in the first place! Anyway,
Blevins tells him he has ballistic reports which prove Mulder's gun fired the "kill
shot" on Ostelhoff, is Mulder prepared to testify that someone else did? Mulder asks
why he's there, to which Blevins replies that Ostelhoff worked for the DoD, and Mulder
says "the man was spying on me!". But for who? No answer. Blevins says Scully
was prepared to name the mole inside the FBI that was plotting against them, namely
Skinner, who they have since learned has been working with a secret agenda, they have
factual evidence against him. But when Mulder asks to see all this so-called proof,
Blevins tells him to name Skinner in his testimony today and the charges against himself
may be dropped. Name Skinner and clear myself? asks Mulder. Yes, Blevins tells him, he is
suggesting this, "as a friend". As soon as he says this, you can see the
hesitation in Mulder's eyes. "I'll see you at the hearing", he tells Blevins,
and walks out.
Mulder goes to see Scully, she's surprised to see him so close to
his scheduled hearing and he tells her he came by the night before, not having the heart
to wake her. "I was lost last night", he says, prepared to make a deal that
could save his life, (the one with Cancer Man) but after Blevins asked him to name
Skinner, he decided against making the deal and he has no intention of naming Skinner.
"We all have our faith, and mine is in the truth." Even if it means being
charged with the Dod Guy's murder. Scully asks "Why'd you come here if you'd already
made up your mind?" and Mulder grins, saying "Because I knew you'd talk me out
of it if I was making a mistake." As Father McCue enters her room, she tells Mulder,
"You'll be in my prayers" and with a kiss on the cheek, he whispers, "Have
the Father say a few Hail Mulders for me, okay?". Hail
Mulders! Cracked me up!
We see the FBI panel waiting not so patiently for Mulder, he arrives
and things REALLY start heating up! Blevins lays out the facts, that the dead man was
killed with Mulder's gun and Mulder interrupts stating that he's ready to name the guilty
parties and put this whole thing to rest. Skinner nervously asks for a recess, but Mulder
looks at him saying that he's ready to proceed. Mulder begins his testimony. He speaks
about Scully's integrity in *not* debunking his work, as she had been ordered to, Blevins
interjects that Scully lied to this panel regarding his death, but Mulder counters that
she lied on his instructions. Mulder begins talking about the conspiracy within the
government, we see the assassin lining up Cancer Man in his sights as he walks down the
street,
Skinner beginning to sweat and look nervous, Scully saying prayers
with Father McCue, Skinner sweating some more, his eyes bulging in fright. Both the Senior
Agent and Blevins ask Mulder whether he shot Ostelhoff, Mulder says he will answer the
question after he names the man responsible for Scully, the man responsible for the
surveillance on his apartment, the man he wants to see prosecuted for his crimes, a man in
this very room. Skinner looks like his sweat glands will explode! The Senior Agent yells
that Blevins has asked Mulder a question, he must
answer, but Mulder says he can't because ... Blevins is the man he's
going to name!
All heck breaks loose now. Cancer Man stands up by his window, the
framed picture of the young Fox and Samantha in his hands, we see a red light on his tie,
he appears to see the light in front of it (this is the tracking beam from the rifle), a
shot rings out. We now see a man with his back to us, on the phone, Blevins enters the
room (it appears to Blevins' office), terrified and out of breath, the man turns around
and hangs up the phone. It's the Senior Agent. He stands up as Blevins rushes towards him
and shoots Blevins in the heart. Down he goes and the Agent wipes off the gun, placing it
in Blevins' hand as he leaves the room. Cancer Man is face down on the floor, he pulls the
cracked picture towards him (looks like a hole in the middle of the glass frame), we can
see blood on his cuff, he closes his eyes and lets out a final breath.
It's now midnight, Mulder is seated outside Scully's room at the
hospital as Skinner approaches. "The Smoking Man is dead", he tells him, shot
through his window. Skinner hands him the picture, minus any frame, with blood streaks on
it, saying that they assume its his blood, no body was found but there was too much blood
loss for anyone to have survived (yeah, right, Cancer Man's NOT dead, I tell ya!). Skinner
asks Mulder how he knew about Blevins, but Mulder says he merely guessed, a darn good
guess as it turns out, Blevins had been on the payroll with Roush, a bio-technical
company, for 4 years. Skinner's not sure how they're connected to all this, and Mulder
says all those connections are right now being erased anyway. Skinner says they're
cleaning up, taking everything away and Mulder smiles, saying "not everything",
Scully's cancer is in remission, the best news he could have heard. When Skinner asks what
caused the remission, Mulder says they'll never know for sure. Skinner goes into Scully's
room, where she's surrounded by her family,
they smile at each other. In the hallway, Mulder looks down at the
picture and begins to cry (probably because with Cancer Man gone, he'll never know where
his sister is).
Notes
I love the explanation Maggie Dorsey <122girls@lightlink.com>
gave for this trilogy. In her own words, used here with her gracious permission: "the
title of the episodes -- Gethsemane and Redux -- are Catholic "things".
Gethsemane was the garden in which Jesus was betrayed by Judas; Redux is the Latin term
for the resurrection, the term used in/by the Catholic church up until the 2nd Vatican
Council, in which mass & other stuff was said in the language of the people (in
America, English) instead of Latin. Chris Carter, who I assume from all this was raised
Catholic, would have been raised during the time when "Redux" was still used. I
think that Gethsemane was the betrayal of Mulder & Scully, Redux I+II their
'resurrection'." I agree wholeheartedly.
Boy oh boy, did the name Roush cause a fuss, huh? Online xphiles,
being the diligent lot they are, rushed to their computers and typed in www.roush.com,
just to see where they ended up. Turned out to be the homepage of pastry giant, Pillsbury!
As we started pointing our fingers at the Pillsbury Doughboy as the evil kingpin we had
long suspected, the story earned an article in the Wall Street Journal, of all places, and
tickled the funny bones at Pillsbury. Bless 'em, they changed the front page to a black
background with the slogan "Believe The Pie". Give the Big Boys some points for
that and go buy some pastries, will ya?
In all seriousness though, what's the deal with the X-Files' Roush?
They seem to be involved with human cloning, which we couldn't help but see throughout the
ep, was it a red herring with regards to Samantha? Or is there some Truth to the
"beautiful lies" Kritschgau told? And did you know that the word
"rauch" means "smoke" in German?! Hmmmm..
I must say that although the reunion with Samantha was darn
touching, I kept begging Mulder to stab her with a fork, see if her blood was red or
green! Why, after seeing all those clones in Colony and End Game, which were played by the
same actress, did he find it so easy to believe this one was real? Her reaction certainly
rang true. If she really had believed she'd been an orphan and this character suddenly
appears saying he's her brother and her mother is indeed alive, I'd be scared out of my
boots as she was. For what it's worth, strong rumour has her signed up for 12 eps this
season, so we just may meet some Mulder nieces and nephews, stay tuned.
Interesting to hear that Samantha has children, probably a husband
as well. As a joke, I speculated that she may be married to the missing Scully brother,
Charles. Where *is* this guy, anyway? Your only sister is dying, fella, show yourself!
More similarites to "The Godfather" here, especially the
ending. My fellow Cult of the Smoking Alien member, Terri, explained to me, as I haven't
seen it, that the ending showed Michael Coreleone (Al Pacino) at his son's christening
(reflected by Scully saying prayers with her priest) as various mob figures get
"whacked" (see Blevins and Cancer Man). In the movie, the priest asks Pacino,
"Do you renounce the devil and all his works?" and, as the camera closes in on
Pacino's eyes, he looks into the camera and says, "Yes". We then hear another
gunshot as someone gets murdered. Spooky stuff!
I really loved the scene where Samantha begged Mulder to "let
her go", sent shivers down my spine. I do believe that he finally did, both
physically and emotionally. Also couldn't help but note a parallel between this scene and
the one right before Mulder's hearing, where Scully appears to *not* want to let Mulder
go.
If you have the three eps on tape, and the time, I suggest watching
them together. The first two really come into focus when viewed with the third. I'm not
what's called a 'shipper, really, as I have no desire to see Mulder and Scully together as
a couple until the final scene of the final episode, whenever that may be, but I *do* have
a heart and this one touched me. The intensity of Mulder's affection for Scully was
palpable. Yup, I'll admit it, I cried, so sue me for being a softie.
Quotes
____________________
Skinner: "You're moving pretty good for a dead man."
Scully: "I've come so far in my life on simple faith, and now
when I need it the most I just push it away. I mean, why ... why do I wear this? (she
picks up the cross necklace around her neck) Why do I wear this, Mom? I put something that
I don't even know, or understand, under the skin of my neck. I will subject myself to
these crazy treatments, and I keep telling myself that I'm doing everything I can, but
it's a lie!"
No live organism can continue for long to exist sanely under conditions of
absolute reality; even larks and katydids are supposed, by some, to dream.
Hill House, not sane, stood by itself against its hills, holding darkness
within; it had stood so for eighty years and might stand for eighty more.
Within, walls continued upright, bricks met neatly, floors were firm, and
doors were sensibly shut; silence lay steadily against the wood and stone
of Hill House, and whatever walked there, walked alone. Shirley Jackson, "The Haunting of Hill House"