Lenny .......................... Vincent Schiavelli
Waiter ......................... Debis Simpson
Glazebrook (older) ............. Blair Slater
Hepcat Helm .................... George Tipple
Glazebrook (younger) ........... Devin Walker
THE MURDER OF A SIDESHOW PERFORMER LEADS MULDER AND SCULLY INTO THE SURREAL WORLD OF
CIRCUS FREAKS, WHERE THEIR SEARCH FOR A KILLER TAKES SOME BIZARRE TURNS INTO AN ALTERNATE
REALITY.
The Alligator Man, a circus performer afflicted with a rare skin disease, is the latest
victim in a series of inexplicable attacks that have ranged over the entire country in the
past few years. When Mulder and Scully arrive to investigate, however, they find an entire
town full of circus performers and carnival freaks. Unraveling the mystery takes them to
the limits of the bizarre and the surrealistic, as they must chase a killer through a
community of freaks. Black humor abounds as the solution to the mystery --and the fate of
the killer -- stuns even the unflappable X-Files team.
Notes
The title is a reference to the great showmaster PT Barnum,
who invented the term "humbug" to mean the selling of some real or fake object
to the public by means of persuasion.
This episode originally aired 3/31/95 - the day before April Fool's Day.
The trailer park is named Gulf Breeze, a place known as a hotbed for UFO sightings.
Jim Rose, the man playing Dr. Blockhead in this ep, is world famous for his travelling
"world of freaks" and The Enigma is one of his featured acts. Those ARE real
crickets he chomps on!
Personal notes: All hail the mighty pen of Darin Morgan! I'm one of those suckers born
every minute that Barnum refers to, and I'm a sucker for Darin's work. A truly classic
episode with wonderful humor, hence the large amount of quotes. I could have printed out
the whole script, it's that good. And there are plenty of gruesome effects to keep the
fans happy, the best being Leonard of course. Great scene where Lenny comes to Scully's
trailor. They're both in bathrobes, he looks at her exposed cleavage, she looks at his
stomach growth, then both cover themselves.
The scene where Scully is invited by the museum curator to see something wonderful is
again based on PT Barnum. He was well-known for doing the same thing. Saying "tell no
soul what you witness here", leading people into a room with an empty box. When the
box was opened, the exit door was triggered, exactly the same as Scully's scene.
Quotes
____________________
Jerry's kid: (to his Dad, the Alligator Man) "Did ya see a lot of weird stuff this
year?"
Mulder: (referring to photo of corpse) "This shows the entry wounds of the
undetermined weapon. There were no other injuries inflicted upon the body, no internal
organs were removed and/or cannibalized, and there's no signs of any sexual molestation,
either."
Eulogist: "...for although Jerry was a world-renowned escape artist, there is one
strongbox from which none of us can escape..." (coffin begins to shake violently, as
if Jerry's about to make an escape, Dr. Blockhead climbs out of grave)
Dr B.: "...But as an admirer of the man's work, I am in a position to perform an
impromptu tribute in his honor! Namely, ramming this spike INTO MY CHEST!"
Sheriff: "...on the inside, they're as normal as anybody."
Scully: "Until their arrest, many serial killers are considered by their friends
and family to be quite normal. If you truly regard these people as normal, then you must
also consider the possibility that they are capable of committing these crimes."
Mulder: "Tell me, have you done much circus work in your life?"
Mr Nutt: "And what makes you think I've ever spectated a circus? Much less been
enslaved by one?"
Mulder: "I know that many of the citizens here are former circus hands, and I just
thought that..."
Mr Nutt: "You thought that because I am a person of short stature, that the only
career I could procure for myself would be one confined to the so-called 'Big Top'. You
took one quick look at me, and decided that you could deduce my entire life. Never did it
occur to you that a person of my height could have possibly obtained a degree in Hotel
Management."
Mulder: "I'm sorry. I meant no offense."
Mr Nutt: "Well then why should I take offense? Just because it's human nature to
make instantaneous judgements of others based solely upon their physical appearances? Why
I've done the same thing to you, for example. I've taken in your all- American features,
your dour demeanor, your unimaginative necktie design, and concluded that you work for the
government; an FBI agent... but do you see the tragedy here? I have mistakenly reduced you
to a stereotype. A caricature, instead of regarding you as a specific, unique
individual."
Mulder: "But I am an FBI agent." (pulls out badge)
Lenny: "Mr. Nut, the kind-hearted manager here, convinced me that to make a living
by publicly displaying my deformity lacked dignity. So... now I carry other people's
luggage. I believe these are your trailers; if they are not... then I am wrong."
Lenny: "Good night, sleep tight, don't let the bedbugs bite. (staggers down the
road, realizes what he said and comes back) No, no, that's...that's not what I meant..
I... I didn't mean to imply that we had bedbugs... I... I meant to say don't let... don't
let the..."
Mulder: "The Fiji mermaids bite."
Bellman: "Yes, that's right... the Fiji Mermaids..."
Mulder: "Have you ever performed this... act on anyone else?"
Dr B: "What, are you sick? I tell my audiences that if they're stupid enough to
try this on themselves they'll end up with a slight lobotomy. I am a professional."
Mulder: "Exactly how does one become a professional Blockhead? May I?" (pulls
out the nail)
Mulder: "I saw him this morning by the river. He was eating a fish."
Dr. B: "He knows between show snacks will ruin his appetite."
Mulder: "I could be mistaken. Maybe it was another bald-headed jigsaw-puzzle
tattooed naked guy I saw."
Scully: "Is this man also a body manipulator?"
Dr B: "No, in the classical sense The Conundrum is a geek."
Mulder: "He eats live animals..."
Dr B: "He eats anything: live animals, dead animals, rocks, light bulbs,
corkscrews, battery cables, cranberries..."
Scully: "Human flesh?"
Dr B: "Only The Conundrum can answer that question. But, he doesn't answer
questions, he merely poses them. When an audience partakes in The Conundrum's human
piranha act, they are left to ask themselves... (feeds Conundrum a fist full of live
crickets) .....why? But, where are my manners?" (offers Scully a cricket-filled jar)
Scully: (takes one) "Thank you." (eats cricket, smiles at Mulder then walks
away. Mulder looks shocked, refuses the crickets)
(Scully pulls cricket she "ate" from behind Mulder's ear)
Scully: "It's an old sleight of hand my uncle taught me. He was only an amateur
magician but he was still better than those two."
Mulder: "Well I'm going over to the lab to see if they can test the blood on the
window against the blood on Dr. Blockhead's nail. (produces nail from mid-air) Everybody's
uncle's an amateur magician."
(after Mulder finds Mr Nutt crawling under Scully's trailer)
Mr Nutt: "I know what you're thinking my friend, but you're grossly
mistaken...Just because I'm not of so-called average height does not mean I must receive
my thrills vicariously. Not all women are attracted to overly tall, lanky men such as
yourself. You'd be surprised how many women find my size intriguingly alluring."
Mulder: "You'd be surprised how many men do as well."
(Mulder and Scully are digging up object buried by sheriff)
Mulder: (pauses from his digging) "Scully, hypertrichosis does not connote
lycanthrophy."
Scully: "What are you implying?"
Mulder: "We're being highly discriminatory here. Just because a man was once
afflicted with excessive hairyness, we've no reason to suspect him of aberrant
behavior."
Scully: "It's like assuming guilt based solely on skin color, isn't it?"
Sheriff: "...I spent the first half of my life as Jim Jim. Then one morning I
noticed a bald spot on top of my head and realized I wasn't only losing my hair but my
career as well. Eventually all the hair went, on top my head anyways. The rest of my
body's still pretty hairy, which is... why I never go to the beach."
Scully: "That doesn't quite explain the potato."
Sheriff: "I got... ah, some warts on my hand."
Mulder: "That doesn't quite explain the potato."
Sheriff: "To get rid of warts, you... rub a sliced potato on your hand and bury it
under a full moon. Investigation isn't going too well, is it?" (Mulder tosses potato
back into hole)
Sheriff: "Now you're sure it was the twin running around here? Now maybe it was
the Fiji Mermaid, he jumped back in the river and swum his way back to Fiji..."
(during Dr. Blockhead's rant about the banality of the future due to genetic
engineering)
Dr B: "...You see, I've seen the future, and the future looks just like
him...[points to Mulder, who is in a classic GQ pose] Imagine, going through your whole
life looking like that. That's why it's left up to the self-made freaks like me 'n The
Conundrum to remind people..."
Scully: "Remind people of what?"
Dr B: "Nature abhors normality. It can't go very long without creating a
mutant."